Difference between revisions of "The Rabbit Hole"

From Insider Outlook
Jump to navigation Jump to search
en>Cmurders
 
 
(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
 
[[Category:Writing]]
 
[[Category:Writing]]
  
−
History is filled with theories and models that were flawed, some more deeply than others. However, they did a good job of explaining and predicting the phenomena they observed in their world. Up to a point, they were totally workable. Later, even when they started to realize that the reference framework was not exactly right, the math still worked well enough for everyday practical use.  
+
The cutting room floor of human history is littered with philosophical, religious, and scientific theories and ideas that were fundamentally flawed, some more deeply than others. However, they did a good job of explaining and predicting the phenomena they had the capability of observing in their world. Up to a point, they were totally workable and useful. Later, even when they started to realize that the reference framework was not exactly right, the math still worked well enough for everyday practical use.  
  
−
If we look at some of them in retrospect, we can see that they were simply incomplete. The original formulation failed to explain new evidence they had not previously observed. In the best cases, adjusting the models fixed the problem. But in others, they needed a better overall paradigm to better explain an increasingly clearer picture of reality.
+
If we look at some of them in retrospect, we can see that they were simply incomplete. The original formulation failed to explain new evidence they had not previously observed. In the best cases, adjusting the models fixed the problem. But in others, they needed a better overall paradigm to better explain an increasingly clearer picture of reality. The truth is, they got better at observation, and the added precision made their initially simple models break down.
  
−
At one time, Europeans believed that the Earth was the center of everything. Even the Mediterranean Sea is named as the Middle of Earth. They had math that could describe and predict the movements of other bodies in this configuration, and scripture seems to indicate the centrality of this creation, so it had to be right. However, one man believed the current model was just too complex to occur naturally. Copernicus thought outside of the accepted model momentarily, and the more obvious solution became clear. The Earth revolved around the Sun. That idea unified the phenomenon of seasons, motions of planets, and the sun's progress along the horizon in one fell swoop. They had a model that was workable prior to Copernicus, but it was not an elegant fit. Reality had to be rewritten, much to the chagrin of the Catholic Church.
+
At one time, Europeans believed that the Earth was the center of everything. Even the Mediterranean Sea is named as the Middle of Earth. They had math that could describe and predict the movements of other bodies in this configuration, and scripture seems to indicate the centrality of this creation, so it had to be right. However, one man believed the mathematical adjustments needed to make to the model work precisely was just too complex for divine fiat. Copernicus thought outside of the accepted model momentarily, and the more obvious solution became clear. The Earth revolved around the Sun. That idea unified the phenomenon of seasons, motions of planets, and the sun's progress along the horizon in one fell swoop. They had a model that was workable prior to Copernicus, but it was not an elegant fit. Reality had to be rewritten, much to the chagrin of the Catholic Church.
  
−
The same can be applied to worldbuilding. You have to start somewhere, but planting those early seeds tempts the writer to grow them out to their full lengths immediately, which might eliminate, conflict with, or severely limit any possible new or overlapping ideas. The philosophical lockstep of scripture and celestial observation was held together by a very thin tether, but deep spiritual, political, and scientific beliefs grew like kudzu around that thin line of reasoning. When it was revealed to be thin and untrustworthy, all of those flowery trappings came tumbling down. This Rabbit Hole of development can sometimes lead to one dimensional tunnel vision, and can create a flat society with predictable plots. A society drawn around a handful of specific archetypes becomes boring quickly. Stereotypes are important for the reader to quickly relate and understand a character, but they need to be varied and complex. There needs to be multiple layers, conflicting ideals, and have spectrums of opinion in order to create something worth reading.
+
The same can be applied to worldbuilding. You have to start somewhere, but planting those early seeds tempts the writer to grow them out to their full lengths immediately, which might eliminate, conflict with, or severely limit any possible new or overlapping ideas. The philosophical lockstep of scripture and celestial observation was held together by a very thin tether, but deep spiritual, political, and scientific beliefs grew like kudzu around that thin line of reasoning. When it was exposed to be a thin and untrustworthy set of assumptions, all of those flowery trappings came tumbling down. This Rabbit Hole of development can sometimes lead to one dimensional tunnel vision, and can create a flat society with predictable plots. A society drawn around a handful of specific archetypes becomes boring quickly. Stereotypes are important for the reader to quickly relate and understand a character, but they need to be distinctly varied and more complex. There needs to be multiple layers, conflicting ideals, and have spectrums of opinion in order to create something worth reading.
  
−
In order to let the whole garden of the story grow together, everything should be elaborated at the same level of detail during early phases of writing. When building the characters and plotlines, it may be better to leave reasons and motivations broad and vague. This is how you can find a workable model, and still have enough room for future growth. Developing detail as it is needed later on is much easier, and you are less likely to break stuff you have already written.
+
In order to let the whole garden of the story grow together, everything should be elaborated at the same level of detail during early phases of writing. When building the characters and plotlines, it may be better to leave reasons and motivations broad and vague. This is how you can find a somewhat workable model, and still have enough room for future growth. Developing detail as it is needed later on is much easier, and you are less likely to break stuff you have already written.
  
−
Creating the bones of a story first, a writer can start draping the hopes, fears, and aspirations on that stable framework without having to rewrite whole sections to make an emotional response more sensible. Start with WHAT happens, and then elaborate on the WHO and WHY in a logical and compelling way that makes the story worth reading. Starting with motivations (WHY) drives the WHAT towards much more predictable actions, requiring a more transparent WHO.
+
Creating the bones of a story first, a writer can start draping the hopes, fears, and aspirations onto that stable framework without having to rewrite whole sections to make an emotional response more sensible. Start with WHAT happens, and then elaborate on the WHO and WHY in a logical and compelling way that makes the story interesting. Starting with motivations (WHY) drives the WHAT towards much more predictable actions, requiring a more transparent WHO.

Latest revision as of 15:46, 29 March 2021

Return to Writing

The cutting room floor of human history is littered with philosophical, religious, and scientific theories and ideas that were fundamentally flawed, some more deeply than others. However, they did a good job of explaining and predicting the phenomena they had the capability of observing in their world. Up to a point, they were totally workable and useful. Later, even when they started to realize that the reference framework was not exactly right, the math still worked well enough for everyday practical use.

If we look at some of them in retrospect, we can see that they were simply incomplete. The original formulation failed to explain new evidence they had not previously observed. In the best cases, adjusting the models fixed the problem. But in others, they needed a better overall paradigm to better explain an increasingly clearer picture of reality. The truth is, they got better at observation, and the added precision made their initially simple models break down.

At one time, Europeans believed that the Earth was the center of everything. Even the Mediterranean Sea is named as the Middle of Earth. They had math that could describe and predict the movements of other bodies in this configuration, and scripture seems to indicate the centrality of this creation, so it had to be right. However, one man believed the mathematical adjustments needed to make to the model work precisely was just too complex for divine fiat. Copernicus thought outside of the accepted model momentarily, and the more obvious solution became clear. The Earth revolved around the Sun. That idea unified the phenomenon of seasons, motions of planets, and the sun's progress along the horizon in one fell swoop. They had a model that was workable prior to Copernicus, but it was not an elegant fit. Reality had to be rewritten, much to the chagrin of the Catholic Church.

The same can be applied to worldbuilding. You have to start somewhere, but planting those early seeds tempts the writer to grow them out to their full lengths immediately, which might eliminate, conflict with, or severely limit any possible new or overlapping ideas. The philosophical lockstep of scripture and celestial observation was held together by a very thin tether, but deep spiritual, political, and scientific beliefs grew like kudzu around that thin line of reasoning. When it was exposed to be a thin and untrustworthy set of assumptions, all of those flowery trappings came tumbling down. This Rabbit Hole of development can sometimes lead to one dimensional tunnel vision, and can create a flat society with predictable plots. A society drawn around a handful of specific archetypes becomes boring quickly. Stereotypes are important for the reader to quickly relate and understand a character, but they need to be distinctly varied and more complex. There needs to be multiple layers, conflicting ideals, and have spectrums of opinion in order to create something worth reading.

In order to let the whole garden of the story grow together, everything should be elaborated at the same level of detail during early phases of writing. When building the characters and plotlines, it may be better to leave reasons and motivations broad and vague. This is how you can find a somewhat workable model, and still have enough room for future growth. Developing detail as it is needed later on is much easier, and you are less likely to break stuff you have already written.

Creating the bones of a story first, a writer can start draping the hopes, fears, and aspirations onto that stable framework without having to rewrite whole sections to make an emotional response more sensible. Start with WHAT happens, and then elaborate on the WHO and WHY in a logical and compelling way that makes the story interesting. Starting with motivations (WHY) drives the WHAT towards much more predictable actions, requiring a more transparent WHO.